Dylann Roof asks 裁判官s to 再考する recusal from his 事例/患者

Dylann Roof wants an entire 控訴裁判所 to 再考する a 決定/判定勝ち(する) to recuse itself from 審理,公聴会 his 事例/患者, as the 控訴,上告 of his death 宣告,判決 and 有罪の判決 in the 2015 人種差別主義者 slayings of nine members of a 黒人/ボイコット South Carolina congregation 勝利,勝つd its way through the judicial system.

Last week, Roof's 弁護士/代理人/検事s made that request of the 4th U.S. 回路・連盟 法廷,裁判所 of 控訴,上告s, 令状ing that the 裁判官s who 選ぶd to sit out his 事例/患者 should 復帰させる themselves to consider his 嘆願(書) for a new 審理,公聴会 before the 法廷,裁判所.

Without that move, or changing a 法廷,裁判所 支配する 禁じるing 裁判官s visiting from other 回路・連盟s from considering such requests, Roof's lawyers wrote, "no 裁判官s 存在する to consider" his rehearing 嘆願(書), 奪うing him of "a 批判的な level of appellate review."

All of the 裁判官s from the 4th 回路・連盟, which covers South Carolina, have recused themselves from 審理,公聴会 Roof's 事例/患者. No explicit 推論する/理由 was given in the 法廷,裁判所´s notice of that move in May, although one of the 裁判官s, Jay Richardson, 起訴するd Roof´s 事例/患者 as an assistant U.S. 弁護士/代理人/検事 in 2017, when Roof became the first person in the U.S. 宣告,判決d to death for a 連邦の hate 罪,犯罪.

当局 have said Roof opened 解雇する/砲火/射撃 during the の近くにing 祈り of a Bible 熟考する/考慮する at Mother Emanuel AME Church in Charleston, South Carolina, raining 負かす/撃墜する dozens of 弾丸s on those 組み立てる/集結するd. He was 21 at the time.

The most 最近の とじ込み/提出するing (機の)カム after the 法廷,裁判所, 特記する/引用するing its recusal, 否定するd Roof's request for a new 審理,公聴会, and also 支配するd against 許すing a 十分な 法廷,裁判所 of 代用品,人 裁判官s from other 回路・連盟s to consider his 事例/患者.

FILE - In this June 18, 2015 file photo, Charlesto
n, S.C., shooting suspect Dylann Storm Roof is escorted from the Cleveland County Courthouse in Shelby, N.C. Attorneys for the federal government have opposed Roof's request for a new appellate hearing, arguing that the South Carolina man was properly convicted and sentenced for the 2015 racist slayings of nine members of a Black congregation. (AP Photo/Chuck Burton, File)

FILE - In this June 18, 2015 とじ込み/提出する photo, Charleston, S.C., 狙撃 嫌疑者,容疑者/疑う Dylann 嵐/襲撃する Roof is 護衛するd from the Cleveland 郡 Courthouse in Shelby, N.C. 弁護士/代理人/検事s for the 連邦の 政府 have …に反対するd Roof's request for a new appellate 審理,公聴会, arguing that the South Carolina man was 適切に 罪人/有罪を宣告するd and 宣告,判決d for the 2015 人種差別主義者 slayings of nine members of a 黒人/ボイコット congregation. (AP Photo/Chuck Burton, とじ込み/提出する)

If Richardson's presence on the 4th 回路・連盟 is indeed the basis for all the 裁判官s' recusal, the 法廷,裁判所 shouldn't let that 詳細(に述べる) 妨げる it from singularly considering Roof's request for a 十分な 審理,公聴会, his 弁護士/代理人/検事s wrote.

"The 法廷,裁判所 does not need to pass on the propriety of 裁判官 Richardson´s 行為/行う at 裁判,公判 to 解決する these 問題/発行するs," they wrote, 追加するing in a footnote that "裁判官 Richardson, of course, has a personal disqualifying 利益/興味 and should remain recused."

In May, a パネル盤 comp osed of 裁判官s from other appellate 回路・連盟s heard Roof´s 事例/患者, subsequently 全員一致で 支持するing his 有罪の判決 and death 宣告,判決 and 問題/発行するing a scathing rebuke of Roof´s 罪,犯罪s.

"No 冷淡な 記録,記録的な/記録する or careful parsing of 法令s and precedents can 逮捕(する) the 十分な horror of what Roof did," the 裁判官s wrote. "His 罪,犯罪s qualify him for the harshest 刑罰,罰則 that a just society can 課す."

In what is 心配するd to be a 非常に長い 控訴,上告s 過程, Roof's lawyers have argued he was wrongly 許すd to 代表する himself during 宣告,判決ing. Roof, his 弁護士/代理人/検事s have said, 首尾よく 妨げるd 賠審員s from 審理,公聴会 証拠 about his mental health, "under the delusion" that "he would be 救助(する)d from 刑務所,拘置所 by white-国家主義者s - but only, bizarrely, if he kept his mental-impairments out of the public 記録,記録的な/記録する."

That 救助(する) notion was 明らかに discussed in some circles. によれば 法廷,裁判所 文書s とじ込み/提出するd in another 連邦の 事例/患者, the 連邦検察局 heard two neo-Nazi group members talk about trying to 解放する/自由な Roof from the 最大限-安全 刑務所,拘置所 in Terre Haute, Indiana, where he is an inmate, 含むing 詳細(に述べる)s on the number of guards 現在の and how a shootout would happen.

If 不成功の in his direct 控訴,上告, Roof could とじ込み/提出する what´s known as a 2255 控訴,上告, or a request that the 裁判,公判 法廷,裁判所 review the 合憲性 of his 有罪の判決 and 宣告,判決. He could also 嘆願(書) the U.S. 最高裁判所 or 捜し出す a 大統領の 容赦.

___

Meg Kinnard can be reached on Twitter at http://twitter.com/MegKinnardAP.

Sorry we are not 現在/一般に 受託するing comments on this article.