税金 専門家 残酷に shuts 負かす／撃墜する woman complaining on TikTok about her $13,000 ATO 法案 when she 推定する／予想するd a 甘い return

• e-mail

An 専門家 has 注ぐd 冷淡な water on the （民事の）告訴 of a woman who took to social マスコミ to lament the ATO asking her for an 付加 $13,000 in 税金 when she had hoped for a rebate.?

Harry Dell, a 税金 lawyer from Sydney, slammed the 欠如（する） of 認識／意識性 around 税金s in a 返答 to?Marina Askew-Panetta, a group sales 経営者／支配人 from the Gold Coast.

Ms?Askew-Panetta was distraught after discovering that after 支払う／賃金ing $48,000 in 税金s over the last 会計年度, she 借りがあるd another large chunk that she に例えるd to a sour Christmas 現在の.?

Mr Dell broke 負かす／撃墜する 正確に／まさに why it was fair for the 政府 to ask her to 支払う／賃金 the same 率s as everybody else.?

Working on what little 詳細（に述べる）s were 利用できる to him, Mr Dell first 概算の Ms?Askew-Panetta likely 年次の income, depending on student 貸付金s.?

Marina Askew-Panetta discovered that after 支払う／賃金ing $48,000 in 税金s over the last 会計年度, she 借りがあるd another $13,000 - which she に例えるd to a sour Christmas 現在の

Harry Dell, a 税金 lawyer from Sydney,?broke 負かす／撃墜する 正確に／まさに why it was fair for the 政府 to ask her to 支払う／賃金 the same 率s as everybody else

Ms Askew-Panetta took to the internet asking for help to understand the 不平等 between her understanding and what lay before her on the ATO website.?

'Can someone please explain to me how I've paid $48,000 in 税金, and 明らかに I [still] 借りがある them $13,034.95,' she said in a ビデオ uploaded to TikTok.

'Merry f****** Christmas babe, I’m f****** shaking.'

Mr Dell was happy to answer the call and explained that based on her 税金 bracket, and whether she had told her 雇用者 about 可能性のある HECS 負債s, it made sense.?

'So, I wake up and I see this rubbish and now I have to make a ビデオ about basic maths,' Mr Dell said in his 返答.?

Mr Dell broke 負かす／撃墜する the 見積（る）s of her salary based on the 税金 she had already paid and what she still 借りがあるd.?

Based on whether she was 返すing student 貸付金s such as a HELP 貸付金 or a HECS 負債, her 支払う／賃金 cheque would likely 落ちる around $160,000 with 返済s, or $195,000 without 返済s.?

The 効果的な 税金 brackets for 返済s on a HELP 貸付金 landed at 39 per cent, and without was 32 per cent.?

'Is this fair? Everyone else on that income has to 支払う／賃金 the same 量,' Mr Dell said.?

Mr Dell did however give Ms?Askew-Panetta the 利益 of the 疑問 関心ing HECS 負債s.

He explained that if she had failed to tell her 雇用者 about 返済s for that then she would have 借りがあるd 概略で $16,000 いっそう少なく in 税金s, which were withheld on her （売買）手数料，委託（する）／委員会／権限s.?

In the end Mr Dell の近くにd out with an 申し込む／申し出 to help Ms?Askew-Panetta とじ込み／提出する her 税金 returns with 十分な comprehension.

'I'm happy to have a look at her 税金 return and tell her how the 税金 return 作品 for her and what her problem likely was,' he said.?

Working with what little 詳細（に述べる）s were 利用できる to him, Mr Dell worked out that Ms Askew-Panetta likely earned between $160,000 to $195,000, depending on student 貸付金s

Those in the comments 株d Mr Dell's argument about people 支払う／賃金ing their fair 株 when it comes to 税金 time.??

'The 量 of people who don’t understand how PAYG [支払う／賃金 as you go] 作品 at 税金 time is astounding,' one person said.

'You’re not stitched up. It’s called 税金. Because you earn a lot,' another 追加するd.?

The 混乱 around HELP 貸付金s and HECS 負債s is a problem for a lot of fresh 卒業生（する）s upon joining the 全労働人口.

従業員s must tell their 雇用者s about any student 負債s so that they can take a 確かな 量 of income ーするために 会合，会う 返済 義務s.?

These sums are held by 雇用者s until 税金 time in a PAYG system, which are then paid in 本体，大部分／ばら積みの without the need for 従業員s to worry about them.

保留するing these 量s is a way to 避ける people 存在 unnecessarily 押し進めるd into higher 税金 brackets because of their seemingly higher 収入s, Mr Dell について言及するd.?

Ms?Askew-Panetta now has until November 21 to 返す the $13,000 to the ATO before they start 非難する her 利益／興味 on the 負債.?