イスラエル is （刑事）被告 of possible war 罪，犯罪 after eight-year-old West Bank boy is 発射 in the 長，率いる and killed as he ran away from IDF

  • Eight-year-old Adam al-Ghul was 発射 dead in November along with a 15-year-old

By David Averre

Published: | Updated:

A UN human 権利s 公式の／役人 has said イスラエル may have committed a war 罪，犯罪 に引き続いて an 調査 into the 狙撃 of two Palestinian boys in the West Bank.

The two children, eight-year-old?Adam al-Ghul and 15-year-old Basel Abu el-Wafa, were 発射 and killed by the Israeli Defence 軍隊s (IDF) in the city of Jenin in November.

Shocking CCTV （映画の）フィート数 of the 出来事/事件 in the West Bank - which is not controlled by Hamas?- showed how the pair appeared to 逃げる from a ひどく armoured IDF 軍用車隊 before 存在 gunned 負かす／撃墜する.?

One 弾丸 攻撃する，衝突する Adam in the 支援する of the 長，率いる, while Basel was 発射 twice in the chest.?

The 十代の少年少女 can be seen struggling on the ground in 明らかな agony for at least half a minute before he died - but Adam was killed 即時に when the Israeli 一連の会議、交渉／完成する 粉々にするd through his skull.?

Eight-year-old?Adam al-Ghul was shot in the head by IDF soldiers in November in the West Bank city of Jenin

Eight-year-old?Adam al-Ghul was 発射 in the 長，率いる by IDF 兵士s in November in the West Bank city of Jenin

Basel Suleiman Tawfiq Abu Al-Wafa, 15, was also killed in the gunfire in November

Basel Suleiman Tawfiq Abu Al-Wafa, 15, was also killed in the 砲火 in November

CCTV footage shows the boy circled in red being shot during an Israeli military raid in Jenin

CCTV （映画の）フィート数 shows the boy circl ed in red 存在 発射 during an Israeli 軍の （警察の）手入れ，急襲 in Jenin

An unexploded Israeli missile lies among the rubble of a destroyed building in the north of Al Nusairat refugee camp, southern Gaza Strip, 29 April 2024

An unexploded Israeli ミサイル lies の中で the がれき of a destroyed building in the north of Al Nusairat 難民 （軍の）野営地，陣営, southern Gaza （土地などの）細長い一片, 29 April 2024

More than 34,300 Palestinians and over 1,455 Israelis have been killed, according to the Palestinian Health Ministry and the Israel Defense Forces (IDF), since Hamas militants launched an attack against Israel from the Gaza Strip on 07 October 2023, and the Israeli operations in Gaza and the West Bank which followed it

More than 34,300 Palestinians and over 1,455 Israelis have been killed, によれば the Palestinian Health 省 and the イスラエル 弁護 軍隊s (IDF), since Hamas 交戦的なs 開始する，打ち上げるd an attack against イスラエル from the Gaza （土地などの）細長い一片 on 07 October 2023, and the Israeli 操作／手術s in Gaza and the West Bank which followed it

In the days after the 狙撃 last year, an 公式の／役人 with the Palestinian Red 三日月 said the children were standing on a 味方する street of central Jenin's main thoroughfare - an area theoretically off 限界s to the Israeli 軍の as it is under the 単独の 支配（する）／統制する of the Palestinian 当局.

But the IDF 軍用車隊 passed them after having been 伴う／関わるd in an 早期に morning （警察の）手入れ，急襲 in Jenin in which the Israeli 軍の （人命などを）奪う，主張するd it killed テロリストs from Palestinian Islamic Jihad.

The （映画の）フィート数 shows how the children were 攻撃する，衝突する by 砲火 from 概略で 40-50 feet away.??

The IDF （人命などを）奪う，主張するd that Basel was 持つ／拘留するing an 爆発性の 装置 when he was 発射, and 公式の／役人s at the time said the '嫌疑者，容疑者／疑うs 投げつけるd 爆発性のs toward IDF 兵士s'.?

The 十代の少年少女 can be seen 持つ／拘留するing something in his 手渡す at the time of the 狙撃, but it is not （疑いを）晴らす what the 反対する was.?

The boys cannot be seen throwing anything at the IDF 軍用車隊 in CCTV （映画の）フィート数, and most of them appeared to be running away when the 砲火 rang out.

Ben Saul, UN special rapporteur on human 権利s, said there was a 可能性 the IDF committed a war 罪，犯罪 in 殺人，大当り the two boys upon reviewing 構成要素s 供給するd by the BBC に引き続いて an 調査 into the 出来事/事件.?

The rapporteur pointed out that there may have been 合法的な grounds for the IDF to （軍隊を）展開する，配備する lethal 軍隊 on Basel if he was in fact 持つ／拘留するing an 爆発性の.

But he said there was no 合法的な justification for the 殺人，大当り of eight-year-old Adam.?

'This appears to be a 違反 of the International 人道的な 法律 禁止s on deliberately, indiscriminately or 不均衡な attacking 非軍事のs, a war 罪，犯罪, and a 違反 of the human 権利 to life,' Saul told the BBC.

The IDF 持続するs that the circumstances surrounding the deaths of the two boys are under review.

But there is little hope the 調査 will turn up findings that could see the 兵士s in question punished or けん責（する），戒告d.?

It comes as human 権利s group 国際アムネスティ said in a 最近の 報告（する）／憶測 that there were several instances in which Israeli 軍隊s （軍隊を）展開する，配備するd disproportionate and unnecessary 軍隊 against 非軍事のs in the West Bank, 行為／行うd unlawful 殺人，大当りs, and 否定するd 医療の 援助 to those 負傷させるd.?

Though the 本体，大部分／ばら積みの of イスラエル's 軍の 操作／手術s are 広げるing in Gaza, the 最新の 人物／姿／数字s 示唆する 492 people have also been killed in the West Bank since October 7.

A BBC investigation into the shooting provided materials to human rights advocates, lawyers and war crimes investigators

A BBC 調査 into the 狙撃 供給するd 構成要素s to human 権利s 支持するs, lawyers and war 罪，犯罪s 捜査官／調査官s

Ben Saul, UN special rapporteur on human rights, said there was a possibility the IDF committed a war crime in killing the two boys upon reviewing materials provided by the BBC following an investigation into the incident

Ben Saul, UN special rapporteur on human 権利s, said there was a 可能性 the IDF committed a war 罪，犯罪 in 殺人，大当り the two boys upon reviewing 構成要素s 供給するd by the BBC に引き続いて an 調査 into the 出来事/事件

Red Crescent first aiders are pictured in action close to the scene of Adam's shooting in Jenin, West Bank, November 2023

Red 三日月 first aiders are pictured in 活動／戦闘 の近くに to the scene of Adam's 狙撃 in Jenin, West Bank, November 2023

Israeli military vehicles travel in a single-file line as a convoy moves through the West Bank city of Jenin

Israeli 軍の 乗り物s travel in a 選び出す／独身-とじ込み／提出する line as a 軍用車隊 moves through the West Bank city of Jenin

イスラエル has long 持続するd its army is の中で the world's most disciplined and says its 軍の 操作／手術s in Gaza are 献身的な to やじ out Hamas.?

IDF 長，指導者 of staff 中尉／大尉／警部補 General Herzi Halevi said that イスラエル's 支配するs of 約束／交戦 - which have not been made public - mean that his men operate によれば 明確に defines parameters and 原則s.

'We cannot fight when discipline and our 原則s are not （疑いを）晴らす and are not followed,' Halevi said recently.?

'A 指揮官 cannot skip 指示／教授／教育s without 是認 if there is no 操作の and self-evident 緊急 推論する／理由 for doing so.'

But a slew of 出来事/事件s in 最近の months appear to show that the IDF is by no means the morally just and disciplined fighting 軍隊 its 指揮官s （人命などを）奪う，主張する.?

Besides the 狙撃 of eight-year-old Adam, an Israeli drone killed seven foreign 援助（する） 労働者s, 含むing three British 国民s, when it 解雇する／砲火／射撃d three separate ミサイルs at three different 乗り物s part of a 明確に 示すd World Central Kitchen 援助（する） 軍用車隊.

The heinous attack 誘発するd international 乱暴／暴力を加える and questions over the IDF's 決定／判定勝ち（する）-making - 特に after two drone 操作者s to ld The Telegraph in December that?they never operate a drone with lethal payload without a lawyer on an uplink, 加える 注目する，もくろむs on the ground and a 上級の officer in the room.

Two 軍の 指揮官s were 解任するd from their 地位，任命するs and a third was けん責（する），戒告d over the strike, with the IDF 最終的に admitting they had mishandled 批判的な （警察などへの）密告，告訴（状） and 侵害する／違反するd the army's 支配するs of 約束／交戦.?

That 出来事/事件 followed the 悲劇の 狙撃 of three Israeli 人質s in Gaza City in December.

A man stands by a destroyed car of the NGO World Central Kitchen (WCK) as it sits along Al Rashid road, between Deir Al Balah and Khan Younis in the southern Gaza Strip

A man stands by a destroyed car of the NGO World Central Kitchen (WCK) as it sits along Al Rashid road, between Deir Al Balah and 旅宿泊所 Younis in the southern Gaza （土地などの）細長い一片

Wreckage of a World Central Kitchen vehicle in Deir Al-Balah, in the central Gaza Strip after seven aid workers - including three British ex-servicemen - were killed in an Israeli drone strike

難破 of a World Central Kitchen 乗り物 in Deir Al-Balah, in the central Gaza （土地などの）細長い一片 after seven 援助（する） 労働者s - 含むing three British ex-servicemen - were killed in an Israeli drone strike?

John Chapman
James 'Jim' Henderson
James Kirby

British 犠牲者s (L-R) John Chapman, 57, James 'Jim' Henderson, 33, and James Kirby, 47, were killed in the attack

Israeli soldiers are pictured in the Gaza Strip as the war rages on between Israel and Hamas

Israeli 兵士s are pictured in the Gaza （土地などの）細長い一片 as the war 激怒（する）s on between イスラエル and Hamas?

Three Israeli hostages killed mistakenly by Israeli forces in Gaza in December had been holding up a white flag. Left to right: Alon Shamriz, Samer El-Talalka and Yotam Haim

Three Israeli 人質s killed 誤った by Israeli 軍隊s in Gaza in December had been 持つ／拘留するing up a white 旗. Left to 権利: Alon Shamriz, Samer El-Talalka and Yotam Haim

The death of the three hostages sparked anger in Israel. Pictured: Relatives and supporters of hostages held by Palestinian militants demonstrate outside the Israeli ministry of defence in Tel Aviv

The death of the three 人質s 誘発するd 怒り／怒る in イスラエル. Pictured: 親族s and 支持者s of 人質s held by Palestinian 交戦的なs 論証する outside the Israeli 省 of defence in Tel Aviv

Yotam Haim, 28, Alon Shamriz, 26, and Samer El-Talalka, 22, were gunned 負かす／撃墜する by 兵士s from their own nation - a shocking 出来事/事件 which?誘発するd fury on the streets of Tel Aviv.

Again, Israeli 公式の／役人s said the 人質s were 解雇する／砲火／射撃d upon against イスラエル's 支配するs of 約束／交戦.

And in the days after the 突発／発生 of war in October, a 選び出す／独身 Israeli airstrike on Jabalia 難民 （軍の）野営地，陣営 is believed to have killed more than 100 非軍事のs.

The 注目する，もくろむ-watering 非軍事の death （死傷者）数 is one of the hallmarks of イスラエル's war in Gaza, and 示唆するs the IDF's alr eady murky 支配するs of 約束／交戦 have been 緩和するd かなり.?

Nearly 35,000 Palestinians have been killed since the IDF 開始する，打ち上げるd its 操作／手術s in Gaza に引き続いて Hamas' October 7 attacks, mostly 予定 to 残虐な 爆破 （選挙などの）運動をするs that have 減ずるd much of Gaza's 組織／基盤／下部構造 to がれき.?

An 調査 by Israeli newspaper Haaretz also 示唆するd in March that the IDF has broken 負かす／撃墜する Gaza into a 網状組織 of '解放する／自由な-解雇する／砲火／射撃 zones' - where any person 現在の is 推定するd a テロリスト and liable to be 扱う／治療するd with lethal 軍隊.

'From our understanding, looking at the IDF's behaviour and 的ing, it makes it （疑いを）晴らす that the 寛容 for 非軍事の [死傷者s] is systematically far worse than in past wars,' Yehuda Shaul, co-創立者 of the thinktank Ofek, told The 後見人.?

  • The BBC's findings are part of a new BBC 文書の which has 調査／捜査するd the 行為／行う of the Israeli 安全 軍隊s in the West Bank. The Other War is 利用できる to watch on BBC iPlayer now or at 9pm this evening on BBC Three
Hamasイスラエル罪，犯罪イスラエル-Hamas