EXCLUSIVE驚くべき／特命の／臨時の 列／漕ぐ／騒動 breaks out between Harvard, Johns Hopkins scientists over origin of mystery 反対する that （機の）カム from outer space

• e-mail

A war of words has 爆発するd between scientists at Harvard, Johns Hopkins and どこかよそで, over a mystery 反対する some argue （機の）カム from outside our solar system.

Last June,?a 研究 探検隊／遠征隊 off the coast of?Papua New Guinea led by Harvard astrophysicist Dr. Avi Loeb dredged up hundreds of small metal spheres from the 太平洋の, which he argues （機の）カム from this 反対する as it melted in 空中 before 衝撃.

In an op-ed for DailyMail.com last August, Dr. Loeb 結論するd that?'the 証拠 示すs the fragments are of interstellar origin.'

But critics of Dr. Loeb, and his E.T.-追跡（する）ing Galileo 事業／計画（する） at Harvard, continue to c hallenge these findings?― which he has 述べるd as a 'truly historic moment' of humanity's first 接触する with '構成要素s from outside our solar system.'

And now the 最新の 実験（する）: A new, 競争相手 分析 of 地震-sensor data used to 跡をつける the 反対する's 2014 衝突，墜落 argues that this sensor never really did 跡をつける an interstellar meteor, much いっそう少なく?a 衝突，墜落ing 外国人 調査（する）, as Dr. Loeb has teased.

This sensor, によれば an international team of Galileo's critics, most likely 選ぶd up only the rumblings of a トラックで運ぶ.

As critics tell DailyMail.com that the Harvard physicist took his team 'on a wild goose chase,' Dr. Loeb has 爆破d the new 熟考する／考慮する as 'unprofessional' and 'a 嘘（をつく）.'

Throughout their two-week 太平洋の voyage last summer, the Galileo team scoured the 海底 for 破片 from the meteor-like 反対する 'IM1,' dragging a 深い-sea 磁石の sled along the fireball's last known trajectory. Pictured is Loeb (権利)?

Dr. Loeb 持続するs his team only used this seismometer's '地震' data to 確認する Department of 弁護 衛星 data on the likely 場所 and trajectory of the meteor-like 反対する, as it 炎d through Earth's atmosphere in 2014.

'As my 同僚 Professor Stein Jacobsen 公式文書，認めるd,' Loeb told DailyMail.com, '"For them to be 権利, the Department of 弁護 衛星s 選ぶd up the signal of a トラックで運ぶ in Papua New Guinea rather than a meteor?"'?

Led by planetary 地震学者 Dr. Benjamin Fernando at Johns Hopkins, the new 研究 looked for patterns across days and nights of the Manus Island seismometer, 指名するd AU MANU, finding 類似の patterns of noise 明確に 関係のない to the meteoric fireball

'The 乱すing reality,' Loeb continued, 'is that some scientists who pretend to defend 証拠-based science, are 急速な／放蕩な to 解任する new 証拠 that goes beyond their knowledge base.'

Fernando's team also used three infrasound sensors to 再評価する the meteor's 上陸 場所／位置. They believe the 磁石の dredging by Loeb's Galileo team last summer might have been looking for sunken fragments of the IM1 meteor (pictured) in the wrong place

But the authors of the competing new paper were no いっそう少なく 批判的な of the Harvard physicist's approach.

That group, led by planetary 地震学者 Dr. Benjamin Fernando at Johns Hopkins, looked for patterns across days and nights of the nearby Manus Island seismometer, AU MANU,?近づく the 場所／位置 of the fireball's 2014 （宇宙船の）着水 in the 太平洋の.

They 報告（する）／憶測 finding many 類似の patterns of seismic noise, 関係のない to the 反対する's fiery 降下／家系.

Their work calls into the question the 分析 of that AU MANU data, which? Dr. Loeb and one of his former students published last year in the 定期刊行物 Signal.

'It was an ordinary トラックで運ぶ,' Dr. Fernando told the New York Times.?'Like a normal トラックで運ぶ 運動ing past a seismometer.'?

Using directional 'azimuth' data from the AU MANU seismometer, Dr. Fernando and his co-authors were able to trace an 明らかな pattern in the signal.??

'The?northward to south-westerly 傾向 of the second (趣旨d meteor) signal is 一貫した with passage along the road in the opposite direction,' they wrote in their paper, which has not yet （疑いを）晴らすd peer-review but is 利用できる at Cornell Tech's pre-print server,?arXiv.

These seismic waves 選ぶd up by the AU MANU seismometer ―?as astrophysicist Dr. Steven Desch, a co-author on the new paper, told DailyMail.com ― are '類似の in wave form to dozens of other events that week.'?

The group 現在のd their 研究 Tuesday as part of a 会議／協議会 組織するd by Houston's Lunar and Planetary 学校／設ける.

Loeb's team searched a patch of the 太平洋の shown above as a '情熱 yellow' square 近づく 'CNEOS C' one of two 可能性のある 衝撃 zone's 概算の by Department of 弁護 data. New 研究 using infrasound and seismometer sensors 示唆するs a different 衝突，墜落 場所／位置, 'IDC'

Three infrasound sensors used by the? 包括的な 実験（する） 禁止（する） 条約 Organisation’s International 監視するing System - ISO4, IS07, and IS37 (above) - were used to calculate this new 査定／評価 of the meteor-like 反対する's 衝突，墜落 場所／位置?

Dr. Fernando's group also 雇うd data from an array of sensors used to 施行する the 包括的な 核の-実験（する）-禁止（する） 条約 to 決定する for themselves where the 反対する (be it a meteor or an 外国人 space 調査（する）) might have most likely 攻撃する，衝突する the 太平洋の.

Their triangulation, which used three of those infrasound sensors, 示唆するs that the 磁石の dredging by Dr. Loeb's Galileo team last summer might have been looking for sunken fragments of the 反対する in the wrong place.?

'If he [Loeb] were honest about the seismometer data, he'd have to 収容する／認める he had no idea where to look.' Dr. Desch said, 'but it's too late for that now.

'He went on a wild goose chase,' Dr. Desch opined, 'now he has egg on his 直面する.'?

'His 返答 to anybody pointing out any of this is to 示唆する we don't 信用 the Department of 弁護.'

But, as 公式文書，認めるd in their paper, Dr. Desch and his 同僚s 充てるd かなりの attention to the public Department of 弁護 meteor data?報告（する）／憶測d to 航空宇宙局's Jet Propulsion 研究室／実験室 for the 反対する, technically 指名するd CNEOS 20140108.

Above a 陰謀（を企てる） of seismic rumbling, as '出来事/事件 velocity 力／強力にする' from the days before and after the IM1 meteor event (red circle). Clusters of loud and 静かな periods, a ccording to Dr. Fernando and his team, 適合する to loud day and 静かな night road traffic. Blue areas are 週末s?

Harvard's Galileo team has since 回復するd many hundreds of unusual アイロンをかける spheres that they believe are likely from the 身元不明の 反対する, known as IM1, off the coast of Papua New Guinea last week as part of a $ 1.5 million underwater search 使節団

READ MORE:? EXCLUSIVE: Truth about my '外国人' 遭遇（する）... How I 設立する bombshell interstellar 反対するs a mile beneath the sea - and their limitless 可能性のある for life on Earth, by scientist AVI LOEB?

Every scientist dreams of making a 広大な／多数の／重要な 発見. A eureka moment when all the 調印するs point to a 結論 that breaks new ground, that 潜在的に changes everything.?

宣伝

His 同僚 Dr. Fernando 公式文書，認めるd that the data 収集するd by the 米国防総省 for its asteroid-跡をつけるing 共同s with 航空宇宙局, the 中心 for 近づく-Earth 反対する 熟考する／考慮するs (CNEOS), identified two 可能性のある 衝撃 zones for the 'fireball' 反対する, 場所／位置s dubbed CNEOS B and C.

Loeb's Galileo team, Dr. Fernando told DailMail.com Monday, only 焦点（を合わせる）d on one of these 場所／位置s, CNEOS C, which was far afield from his teams' infrasound-based 計算／見積り of the 衝撃 zone.

'The best that we can do with the 明言する／公表する of the art 核の 監視するing sensors is get an area of about 300,000 square-キロメーターs, 227,000 square キロメーターs,' Dr. Fernando told DailyMail.com Monday.

'And that's not because the data is no good. It's not because the sensors are no good,' he 追加するd.?

'It's just because it's an 極端に weak signal. And we don't have an exact model for what the atmosphere was like 支援する in 2014,' a 言及／関連 to how 天候 might have scattered the melting, 落ちるing 破片.

Dr. Loeb, however, 残り／休憩（する）d his rebuttal on the 幅の広い 不確定 and 大規模な square-キロメーター surface area 決定するd by his critics' new 研究, which he 公式文書，認めるd, happens to 含む the area where his team 行為／行うd their 磁石の dredging for the mystery 反対する's 衝突，墜落d 破片.

'Ben Fernando and 同僚s 簡単に 解任するd the Department of 弁護 data for the localization of the meteor,'?Dr. Loeb wrote DailyMail.com.

'This is an 無効の argument.'?

Both Dr. Loeb's 2023 定期刊行物 article in Signal, 同様に as a public 告示 from US Space 命令（する）, 示す that his Galileo team received corroborativ e 援助 from 極度の慎重さを要する DoD 衛星 data that is not 利用できる to the public.

'It is unprofessional for him to （人命などを）奪う，主張する that the DoD [Department of 弁護] box is incorrect because his much larger 地域 含む／封じ込めるs other points,' Loeb said.

'We went to the DoD box and only used seismometer data to 実証する the DoD box.'?